How to Make Dairy Free Condensed Milk (Bold Baking Basics)
Save RecipeHi Bold Bakers!
The only difference between Dairy Free Condensed Milk and regular Condensed Milk is the milk used. Dairy Free Condensed milk is made using coconut milk rather than dairy milk. However the Condensed milk can be used in the exact same way as regular in your Vegan and Dairy Free baking. Use it in any recipe that calls for regular condensed milk.
You can also use Nut Milks and other sugars such as Stevia. See the Notes section in the recipe.
I use Condensed Milk a lot in my baking. It is one of the main ingredients in my 2 Ingredient No Machine Ice Cream. I make a delicious Dairy Free No Machine Ice Cream that is equally as delicious with a variety of flavors to make. If you like your frozen desserts a little lighter and fruity then try my Homemade Sorbet in 5 minutes (No Machine) If you cannot find condensed milk in your country you can easily make it yourself at home. And you can find my regular Homemade Condensed Milk recipe here.
Simmering milk and sugar on a low, controlled heat will yield you a thick, syrupy milk.
Once it cools it will thicken and be ready to use. It will last in the fridge for weeks if you don’t need it straight away.
- 1 can (14 oz/414 ml/2 cups) coconut milk (full fat or low fat)*
- ⅔ cups (5 ⅓ oz / 150g) white sugar
-
Add the coconut milk and sugar into a heavy bottomed saucepan
-
Heat it on a low heat until the sugar has dissolved
-
Once all of the sugar has dissolved bring the mix to a simmer over low/medium heat. Do not stir once the mix starts to simmer otherwise it can crack and crystalize
-
Gently simmer for roughly 30- 40 minutes, or until the milk has darkened to an almost grey color,has reduced by half and thickened (After about 15 minutes, you'll notice that the milk will start to turn dark and thicken – that's ok and is exactly what's supposed to happen)
-
When ready, remove from the heat and pour into a jar to cool. (if there are sugary bits hanging around the rim of your pot don’t stir them into your condensed milk, this can also crack your mix)
-
Let the condensed milk cool completely before putting on the air tight lid.
-
Store in a jar in the fridge and it will last for months. Don't forget to label it. 🙂
The condensed milk when ready will measure 1 cup/8oz.
You can replace the regular milk with any other dairy free milk
You can Replace the sugar with a natural sugar like maple syrup, agave, or coconut sugar.
Meet Gemma
Hi Bold Bakers! I’m Gemma Stafford, a professional chef originally from Ireland, and I’m passionate about sharing my years of experience to show you how to make game-changing baking recipes with over-the-top results! Join more than 1 Million other Bold Bakers in the community for new video recipes every week!
Have you made a recipe? Share photos on my website or across social media with the hashtag #boldbaker.
And don't miss my NEW Bold Baking recipes and tips. Sign up for my weekly email newsletter.
I’m sorry, I just asked about coconut sugar and I read the bottom of the recipe, oops! Ha ha! 😁
Hi Gemma!
Love your recipes! I know people are asking a lot about the sugar… how about coconut sugar? Do you think that will work?
Would this work if the sugar was replaced with erythritol, xylitol or monk fruit sweetener?
Hi Colleen! Great question as we’ve had Bold Bakers ask us about this. The substitute you use needs to be able to caramelize. Unfortunately, stevia, xylitol, splenda will not caramelize so will not work in this recipe.
Hi Gemma
I’m using coconut milk and it has been simmering over 40 minutes and hasn’t thickened. Should I keep simmering it?
Hi Helen,
tell me about the sugar. The idea is that the sugar will dissolve and get to the ‘soft ball’ stage of caramel, which, even if you are using sugar and water, will thicken. It cannot thicken if the sugar quantity is not right.
Let me know,
Gemma 🙂
Oh Gemma
So lovely to hear from you. U just don’t know why it took so long to thicken. I put 2/3 cup of sugar and the trouble is it kept leaving a whitish layer and I removed it whenever I could. I tried the whitish part and it was like condensed milk which was beautiful but the liquid in the saucepan stayed the same. After hours on the stove simmering I decided to take it off and put it in the fridge but when I checked it, it was hard as a rock.
Thanks again
Helen
Oh Helen, poor you! I am not too sure where this went wrong. I hope you will take another chance with it, it really does work!
Gemma 🙂
Is cashew milk okay to use in the recipe?
Hi there,
Yes, you can use any milk. What you are doing is reducing the water content by slowly evaporating it while caramelizing the sugars with the residue and remaining water. The result will be a little different and you may need to watch it carefully. Fully dissolve all of the sugar before you simmer it, then you are looking for the soft ball stage, not coloring, just thickening the milk. I suggest you try a sample so that you do not waste it.
Gemma 🙂
I am wondering if I could use Splenda for the sugar in this recipe.
Hi Amy,
Unfortunately for this recipe you can’t use splenda because it doesn’t not caramelize. We re working on a refined sugar free version.
Watch this space.
Gemma.
Hi Gemma, I love your videos and recipes. Could I possibly use lactaid milk to make the sweetened condensed milk?
I love the coconut milk one, but would like to try it without a coconut flavor.
Keep the recipes coming.
Hi Karen,
Yes you can use that milk, no problem :).
Hope it turns out well,
Gemma.
Hi, would it work with lactose free milk?
Hi, yes that would work here.
Hi Gemma –
I need to make dairy and sugar free condensed milk. Will stevia or Swerve work in this recipe?
Hi Carol,
this is the big question! Stevia will not work, Swerve/Lakanto/Truvia etc will work rather better. The issue is that sugars need to caramelize in order to thicken the milk, which is a bit like the soft ball stage of the caramel making process. The alcohol sugars/Truvia etc. will sort of caramelize, but I have not tried it, though it is on my list.
It depends on what you wish to use it for too. For my ice cream recipes it may not be thick enough, but we really do noeed to do some work on it. One bols baker thickened hers with a little cornstarch! she reported that this worked well for her.
Not much help I know, do let us know if you try it,
Gemma 🙂
Thank you so much for the advice. I am going to make lime cheesecake bars, so I may add a little cornstarch to thicken it.
That is the idea Carol, and for that recipe I think that will be perfect,
Gemma 🙂
My Key Lime cheesecake bars turned out just fine with this recipe – plus a little cornstarch. Didn’t taste too much coconut, either.
Carol
Great job! I’m delighted to hear that, next time send us a photo!
Hi Gemma
Does coconut milk taste like coconut? I’ve never used it & really don’t like coconut. Wondering how it would taste in other recipes.
Thanks
Sandy
Hi, yes it does have a slight coconut flavor, but it is very neutral. I love it!
will this work with coconut cream? I have a bunch of cans of coconut cream hahaha just seeing what i can do with them.
Hi, yes that will work here too!
I made this recipe but with soy milk and it just would not thicken.
Yes, for this i suggest yous stick to coconut milk.
Can Stevia be used, quantity?
Hi, this does not reduce down the same with out the sugar.
since I can use coconut milk , will almond milk as well? I’ve tried to make pudding with almond milk with out success.. wondered if you have tried for condensed milk..
Hi Mona,
I have not tried with almond milk. That said, ant milk should condense. What you are doing is evaporating the water content, and thickening the milk residue with the sugars, almost to a caramel. I cannot see why it would not work. See this recipe too (https://www.biggerbolderbaking.com/vegan-chocolate-pudding/) you may like it!
Gemma 🙂
hi gemma,
can i use fresh coconut milk for this recipe.
Hi there,
Short answer YES! that wil lbe perfect,
Gemma 🙂